Dossier Fruity Vanilla vs Oakcha Silent Melody

Atlas reviewed. Here's how they stack up on performance, accuracy and value.

Both fragrances are inspired by Burberry Goddess.

At a glance

Dossier Fruity Vanilla costs £39 and Oakcha Silent Melody costs £31, so Oakcha Silent Melody is £8 cheaper. They share 3 notes out of 12 distinct notes listed across both (25%). Dossier Fruity Vanilla is EDP and listed as feminine, while Oakcha Silent Melody is Extrait and listed as feminine. Both are inspired by Burberry Goddess.

Dossier Fruity Vanilla

Fruity Vanilla is Dossier's interpretation of Burberry Goddess, combining pear, ginger and mandarin with peach, jasmine and lavender before a rich vanilla, caramel and tonka bean drydown.

Oakcha Silent Melody

Silent Melody is a feminine Extrait de Parfum from Oakcha built around vanilla, lavender, cocoa and ginger over vanilla caviar before vanilla absolute dominates the base. It is Oakcha's direct interpretation of Burberry Goddess, concentrating the lavender and multi vanilla structure into a denser format.

Dossier Fruity Vanilla, dupe of Burberry GoddessOakcha Silent Melody, dupe of Burberry Goddess

Comparison

Dossier Fruity VanillaOakcha Silent Melody
Overall rating7.8/10 · 1 review7.8/10 · 1 review
Longevity7.5/107.5/10
Projection7.0/107.0/10
Scent accuracy8.0/108.5/10
Value for money8.5/108.0/10
Price£39£31
ConcentrationEDPExtrait
GenderFeminineFeminine
Inspired byBurberry GoddessBurberry Goddess

Notes Comparison

Compare the note structure of both fragrances and see which notes they share.

Dossier Fruity Vanilla

Top Notes

  • Pear
  • Ginger
  • Mandarin

Heart Notes

  • Peach
  • Jasmine
  • Lavender

Base Notes

  • Vanilla
  • Caramel
  • Tonka Bean

Oakcha Silent Melody

Top Notes

  • Vanilla
  • Lavender
  • Cocoa
  • Ginger

Heart Notes

  • Vanilla Caviar

Base Notes

  • Vanilla Absolute

Shared Notes

  • Ginger
  • Lavender
  • Vanilla

3 shared notes.

How the notes differ

Dossier Fruity Vanilla lists Pear, Mandarin, Peach, Jasmine, Caramel and Tonka Bean that Oakcha Silent Melody does not.

Oakcha Silent Melody lists Cocoa, Vanilla Caviar and Vanilla Absolute that Dossier Fruity Vanilla does not.

Accords, vibes and occasions

Main accords

Dossier Fruity Vanilla

  • Vanilla
  • Fruity
  • Sweet
  • Caramel
  • Warm spicy
  • Floral
  • Powdery

Oakcha Silent Melody

  • Sweet
  • Vanilla
  • Powdery
  • Aromatic
  • Lavender
  • Cacao
  • Warm spicy
  • Spicy

Both share Vanilla, Sweet, Warm spicy and Powdery. Dossier Fruity Vanilla also lists Fruity, Caramel and Floral. Oakcha Silent Melody also lists Aromatic, Lavender, Cacao and Spicy.

Vibes

Dossier Fruity Vanilla

  • Decadent
  • Sweet
  • Warm
  • Feminine
  • Modern

Oakcha Silent Melody

  • Clean
  • Sweet
  • Warm
  • Feminine

Both share Sweet, Warm and Feminine. Dossier Fruity Vanilla also lists Decadent and Modern. Oakcha Silent Melody also lists Clean.

Occasions

Dossier Fruity Vanilla

  • Autumn
  • Winter
  • Evening
  • Date Night
  • Everyday

Oakcha Silent Melody

  • Evening
  • Autumn
  • Spring
  • Everyday

Both share Autumn, Evening and Everyday. Dossier Fruity Vanilla also lists Winter and Date Night. Oakcha Silent Melody also lists Spring.

Performance

Dossier Fruity Vanilla

  • Strong Projection
  • Long Wearing

Oakcha Silent Melody

  • Long lasting

Dossier Fruity Vanilla lists Strong Projection and Long Wearing. Oakcha Silent Melody lists Long lasting.

Style lane

Dossier Fruity Vanilla

  • Fruity vanilla gourmand

Oakcha Silent Melody

  • Warm spicy

Dossier Fruity Vanilla lists Fruity vanilla gourmand. Oakcha Silent Melody lists Warm spicy.

Quick verdict

  • Longevity: Tie (7.5/10)
  • Projection: Tie (7.0/10)
  • Scent accuracy: Wins Oakcha Silent Melody (8.5/10)
  • Value for money: Wins Dossier Fruity Vanilla (8.5/10)
  • Price: Wins Oakcha Silent Melody (£31)

Dossier Fruity Vanilla leads on value for money, while Oakcha Silent Melody leads on scent accuracy and lower price. They are level on longevity and projection.

Atlas ratings combine Scent Atlas community ratings with Atlas AI Analysis. Dossier Fruity Vanilla has 1 community review and Oakcha Silent Melody has 1.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is cheaper, Dossier Fruity Vanilla or Oakcha Silent Melody?

Dossier Fruity Vanilla costs £39 and Oakcha Silent Melody costs £31, so Oakcha Silent Melody is £8 cheaper.

Which lasts longer, Dossier Fruity Vanilla or Oakcha Silent Melody?

Atlas ratings give Dossier Fruity Vanilla 7.5 out of 10 for longevity and Oakcha Silent Melody 7.5 out of 10, so they rate the same.

Which projects more, Dossier Fruity Vanilla or Oakcha Silent Melody?

Atlas ratings give Dossier Fruity Vanilla 7.0 out of 10 for projection and Oakcha Silent Melody 7.0 out of 10, so they rate the same.

Which is closer to Burberry Goddess, Dossier Fruity Vanilla or Oakcha Silent Melody?

Atlas ratings give Dossier Fruity Vanilla 8.0 out of 10 for scent accuracy and Oakcha Silent Melody 8.5 out of 10, so Oakcha Silent Melody rates higher.

Which is better value, Dossier Fruity Vanilla or Oakcha Silent Melody?

Atlas ratings give Dossier Fruity Vanilla 8.5 out of 10 for value for money and Oakcha Silent Melody 8.0 out of 10, so Dossier Fruity Vanilla rates higher.

What notes do Dossier Fruity Vanilla and Oakcha Silent Melody share?

They share 3 notes: Ginger, Lavender and Vanilla.

Which occasions suit Dossier Fruity Vanilla and Oakcha Silent Melody?

Dossier Fruity Vanilla is tagged for Autumn, Winter, Evening, Date Night and Everyday. Oakcha Silent Melody is tagged for Evening, Autumn, Spring and Everyday.

Atlas ratings combine Scent Atlas community ratings with Atlas AI Analysis.

Compare with the original

  • Burberry Goddess vs Dossier Fruity Vanilla
  • Burberry Goddess vs Oakcha Silent Melody

See the full Fruity Vanilla breakdown

See the full Silent Melody breakdown

THE SCENT ATLAS