Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir vs Dossier Musky Green Tea
Atlas reviewed. Here's how they stack up on performance, accuracy and value.
Both fragrances are inspired by Creed Silver Mountain Water.
At a glance
Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir costs £96.96 and Dossier Musky Green Tea costs £39, so Dossier Musky Green Tea is £57.96 cheaper. They share 5 notes out of 11 distinct notes listed across both (45%). Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir is Extrait and listed as masculine, while Dossier Musky Green Tea is EDP and listed as unisex. Both are inspired by Creed Silver Mountain Water.
Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir
Frankel Silver Elixir is a fresh aquatic composition built around green tea, blackcurrant and a sandalwood jasmine base, inspired by Creed Silver Mountain Water.
Dossier Musky Green Tea
Musky Green Tea is Dossier’s crystalline, cooling interpretation of Creed Silver Mountain Water, built around sparkling green tea freshness, airy citrus florals, and a clean musky sandalwood base that feels pure, bright, and effortlessly transportive.
Comparison
| Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir | Dossier Musky Green Tea | |
|---|---|---|
| Overall rating | 7.5/10 · 1 review | 7.8/10 · 1 review |
| Longevity | 7.5/10 | 7.6/10 |
| Projection | 7.0/10 | 6.8/10 |
| Scent accuracy | 8.0/10 | 8.2/10 |
| Value for money | 7.5/10 | 8.5/10 |
| Price | £96.96 | £39 |
| Concentration | Extrait | EDP |
| Gender | Masculine | Unisex |
| Inspired by | Creed Silver Mountain Water | Creed Silver Mountain Water |
Notes Comparison
Compare the note structure of both fragrances and see which notes they share.
Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir
Top Notes
Heart Notes
Base Notes
Dossier Musky Green Tea
Top Notes
Heart Notes
Base Notes
Shared Notes
5 shared notes.
How the notes differ
Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir lists Orange, Lemon, Bergamot, Galbanum and Jasmine that Dossier Musky Green Tea does not.
Dossier Musky Green Tea lists Neroli that Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir does not.
Accords, vibes and occasions
Main accords
Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir
Dossier Musky Green Tea
Both share Citrus and Green. Dossier Musky Green Tea also lists Woody, Fresh, Musky, Floral, Fruity, Earthy, Aquatic, Aromatic, Bitter and Mineral.
Vibes
Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir
Dossier Musky Green Tea
Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir lists Sweet and Confident. Dossier Musky Green Tea lists Fresh, Clean, Dark, Warm and Aquatic.
Occasions
Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir
Dossier Musky Green Tea
Both share Daytime. Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir also lists Evening. Dossier Musky Green Tea also lists Signature, Office, Spring, Summer and Travel.
Performance
Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir
Dossier Musky Green Tea
Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir lists Good projection and Good longevity. Dossier Musky Green Tea lists Sillage and Excellent longevity.
Style lane
Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir
Dossier Musky Green Tea
Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir lists Citrus aromatic. Dossier Musky Green Tea lists Clean musky.
Quick verdict
- Longevity: Wins Dossier Musky Green Tea (7.6/10)
- Projection: Wins Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir (7.0/10)
- Scent accuracy: Wins Dossier Musky Green Tea (8.2/10)
- Value for money: Wins Dossier Musky Green Tea (8.5/10)
- Price: Wins Dossier Musky Green Tea (£39)
Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir leads on projection, while Dossier Musky Green Tea leads on longevity, scent accuracy, value for money and lower price.
Atlas ratings combine Scent Atlas community ratings with Atlas AI Analysis. Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir has 1 community review and Dossier Musky Green Tea has 1.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is cheaper, Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir or Dossier Musky Green Tea?
Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir costs £96.96 and Dossier Musky Green Tea costs £39, so Dossier Musky Green Tea is £57.96 cheaper.
Which lasts longer, Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir or Dossier Musky Green Tea?
Atlas ratings give Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir 7.5 out of 10 for longevity and Dossier Musky Green Tea 7.6 out of 10, so Dossier Musky Green Tea rates higher.
Which projects more, Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir or Dossier Musky Green Tea?
Atlas ratings give Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir 7.0 out of 10 for projection and Dossier Musky Green Tea 6.8 out of 10, so Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir rates higher.
Which is closer to Creed Silver Mountain Water, Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir or Dossier Musky Green Tea?
Atlas ratings give Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir 8.0 out of 10 for scent accuracy and Dossier Musky Green Tea 8.2 out of 10, so Dossier Musky Green Tea rates higher.
Which is better value, Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir or Dossier Musky Green Tea?
Atlas ratings give Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir 7.5 out of 10 for value for money and Dossier Musky Green Tea 8.5 out of 10, so Dossier Musky Green Tea rates higher.
What notes do Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir and Dossier Musky Green Tea share?
They share 5 notes: Green Tea, Blackcurrant, Petitgrain, Sandalwood and Musk.
Which occasions suit Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir and Dossier Musky Green Tea?
Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir is tagged for Evening and Daytime. Dossier Musky Green Tea is tagged for Signature, Daytime, Office, Spring, Summer and Travel.
Atlas ratings combine Scent Atlas community ratings with Atlas AI Analysis.
Compare with the original
- Creed Silver Mountain Water vs Assaf Frankel Silver Elixir
- Creed Silver Mountain Water vs Dossier Musky Green Tea