ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel vs Atralia Tonka Gold

Atlas reviewed. Here's how they stack up on performance, accuracy and value.

Both fragrances are inspired by Kilian Angels' Share.

At a glance

ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel costs £39 and Atralia Tonka Gold costs £25, so Atralia Tonka Gold is £14 cheaper. They share 3 notes out of 10 distinct notes listed across both (30%). ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel is EDP and listed as unisex, while Atralia Tonka Gold is Extrait and listed as masculine. Both are inspired by Kilian Angels' Share.

ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel

Amber Angel is ALT. Fragrances' comparison to Kilian Paris Angels' Share, the cognac and praline gourmand that turned a whiskey barrel accord into one of niche perfumery's most recognisable signatures.

Atralia Tonka Gold

Atralia Tonka Gold is a deep amber gourmand fragrance that captures the luxurious masculine DNA of Kilian Angels’ Share through warm spice, creamy tonka sweetness, and a smooth woody vanilla base.

ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel, dupe of Kilian Angels' ShareAtralia Tonka Gold, dupe of Kilian Angels' Share

Comparison

ALT. Fragrances Amber AngelAtralia Tonka Gold
Overall rating7.9/10 · 1 review8.0/10 · 1 review
Longevity7.8/108.2/10
Projection7.2/107.5/10
Scent accuracy8.5/107.8/10
Value for money8.2/108.5/10
Price£39£25
ConcentrationEDPExtrait
GenderUnisexMasculine
Inspired byKilian Angels' ShareKilian Angels' Share

Notes Comparison

Compare the note structure of both fragrances and see which notes they share.

ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel

Top Notes

  • Cognac
  • Oak Wood

Heart Notes

  • Tonka Bean

Base Notes

  • Sandalwood
  • Praline
  • Vanilla

Atralia Tonka Gold

Top Notes

  • Cardamom
  • Fig

Heart Notes

  • Iris
  • Black Tea

Base Notes

  • Tonka Bean
  • Sandalwood
  • Vanilla

Shared Notes

  • Tonka Bean
  • Sandalwood
  • Vanilla

3 shared notes.

How the notes differ

ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel lists Cognac, Oak Wood and Praline that Atralia Tonka Gold does not.

Atralia Tonka Gold lists Cardamom, Fig, Iris and Black Tea that ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel does not.

Accords, vibes and occasions

Main accords

ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel

  • Sweet
  • Amber
  • Citrus
  • Vanilla
  • Gourmand
  • Fruity
  • Whiskey

Atralia Tonka Gold

  • Sweet
  • Woody
  • Amber
  • Vanilla
  • Gourmand
  • Fruity
  • Powdery
  • Aromatic
  • Iris
  • Warm spicy
  • Spicy

Both share Sweet, Amber, Vanilla, Gourmand and Fruity. ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel also lists Citrus and Whiskey. Atralia Tonka Gold also lists Woody, Powdery, Aromatic, Iris, Warm spicy and Spicy.

Vibes

ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel

  • Sweet
  • Warm
  • Modern
  • Gourmand

Atralia Tonka Gold

  • Clean
  • Sweet
  • Bold
  • Elegant
  • Warm
  • Masculine
  • Gourmand
  • Compliment
  • Luxurious

Both share Sweet, Warm and Gourmand. ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel also lists Modern. Atralia Tonka Gold also lists Clean, Bold, Elegant, Masculine, Compliment and Luxurious.

Occasions

ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel

  • Signature
  • Evening
  • Autumn
  • Winter
  • Night out
  • Cooler weather

Atralia Tonka Gold

  • Formal
  • Colder weather

ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel lists Signature, Evening, Autumn, Winter, Night out and Cooler weather. Atralia Tonka Gold lists Formal and Colder weather.

Performance

ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel

  • Long lasting

Atralia Tonka Gold

  • Strong projection
  • Long lasting
  • Subtle

Both share Long lasting. Atralia Tonka Gold also lists Strong projection and Subtle.

Style lane

ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel

  • Boozy gourmand

Atralia Tonka Gold

  • Spicy amber

ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel lists Boozy gourmand. Atralia Tonka Gold lists Spicy amber.

Quick verdict

  • Longevity: Wins Atralia Tonka Gold (8.2/10)
  • Projection: Wins Atralia Tonka Gold (7.5/10)
  • Scent accuracy: Wins ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel (8.5/10)
  • Value for money: Wins Atralia Tonka Gold (8.5/10)
  • Price: Wins Atralia Tonka Gold (£25)

ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel leads on scent accuracy, while Atralia Tonka Gold leads on longevity, projection, value for money and lower price.

Atlas ratings combine Scent Atlas community ratings with Atlas AI Analysis. ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel has 1 community review and Atralia Tonka Gold has 1.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is cheaper, ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel or Atralia Tonka Gold?

ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel costs £39 and Atralia Tonka Gold costs £25, so Atralia Tonka Gold is £14 cheaper.

Which lasts longer, ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel or Atralia Tonka Gold?

Atlas ratings give ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel 7.8 out of 10 for longevity and Atralia Tonka Gold 8.2 out of 10, so Atralia Tonka Gold rates higher.

Which projects more, ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel or Atralia Tonka Gold?

Atlas ratings give ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel 7.2 out of 10 for projection and Atralia Tonka Gold 7.5 out of 10, so Atralia Tonka Gold rates higher.

Which is closer to Kilian Angels' Share, ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel or Atralia Tonka Gold?

Atlas ratings give ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel 8.5 out of 10 for scent accuracy and Atralia Tonka Gold 7.8 out of 10, so ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel rates higher.

Which is better value, ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel or Atralia Tonka Gold?

Atlas ratings give ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel 8.2 out of 10 for value for money and Atralia Tonka Gold 8.5 out of 10, so Atralia Tonka Gold rates higher.

What notes do ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel and Atralia Tonka Gold share?

They share 3 notes: Tonka Bean, Sandalwood and Vanilla.

Which occasions suit ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel and Atralia Tonka Gold?

ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel is tagged for Signature, Evening, Autumn, Winter, Night out and Cooler weather. Atralia Tonka Gold is tagged for Formal and Colder weather.

Atlas ratings combine Scent Atlas community ratings with Atlas AI Analysis.

Compare with the original

  • Kilian Angels' Share vs ALT. Fragrances Amber Angel
  • Kilian Angels' Share vs Atralia Tonka Gold

See the full Amber Angel breakdown

See the full Tonka Gold breakdown

THE SCENT ATLAS